Showing posts with label polygamy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label polygamy. Show all posts

Monday, April 21, 2008

Hoax Motivations

Turns out the call that "justified" the raid on the ranch in Eldorado Texas was possibly a hoax.
"The possibility exists that Rozita Swinton, who has nothing to do with the FLDS church, may have been a woman who made calls and pretended she was the 16-year-old girl named Sarah," CNN's Gary Tuchman reported. Swinton, 33, has been charged in Colorado with false reporting to authorities and is in police custody. Police said that arrest was not directly related to the Texas case.
Now, I can sometimes appreciate a practical joke (especially when there's rubber chickens or other freebirds involved), but why would someone do this? I read a few articles about her. It's likely she didn't do this to help the children. She was arrested in Colorado for hoaxing that she was a kidnapped child locked in a basement, sending police on a wild goose chase. When they finally traced the call to her, they found in her home evidence suggesting she was behind the call that provoked the FLDS raid in Texas, too.

She also probably didn't hoax out of anti-FLDS/YFZ bigotry. She seems, in my far removed and layman's opinion, to be just some sicko who thinks it's funny to get people riled up. Got the police so scared about a fictional child that they took ridiculously unconstitutional measures. Terrified the people they investigated, too. That's just disgusting.

Monday, April 14, 2008

Something smells rotten in Denmark, Texas.

This whole thing about the West Texas raid is pretty sticky. On the one hand, the government had justification to believe at least some of the children were in danger. On the other hand, I'm not a big fan of the government taking drastic measures en masse against it's citizenry.

Clearly we don't evenly persecute those who define marriage a little unconventionally. (Ain't that right, Newt?) It'd be easy to get the wrong message from this whole situation. It's not entirely unfair to argue that the gov't position can be summarized as "Swinging, premarital sex, and even breaking your marriage vows are all just fine. Exchanging marriage vows with more than one person, however, is unforgivable, regardless of whether all involved are aware and fine with it."

As I understand it, in response to allegations that one person had abused one child, the government took 416 children away from their families. Does that feel like a fair and reasonable response to you? Doesn't it seem that maybe the FLDS folks could have some justification in feeling this was religiously persecution?
Utah Attorney General Mark Shurtleff said prosecuting polygamy is difficult for three reasons. One, the numbers are formidable. Two, these crimes are extremely difficult to prosecute. And three, is the issue of fairness and past history - the Short Creek raid in 1953 - which Shurtleff said was a colossal failure.

Shurtleff said if polygamy were prosecuted, the issue would become whether there were enough prison cells for the thousands of men and homes for the thousands of women and children.

In fairness, Shurtleff said, adultery, fornication and sodomy are also against the law. While the fornication and sodomy laws would not be able to stand a legal challenge, states do have the right to define and regulate marriage.

Adultery destroys marriages and families, but he does not hear the same public outcry to prosecute adulterers, Shurtleff said.
Don't get me wrong. Absolutely the right move was to remove that child, and all other children, from that household pending an investigation. And with polygamy, households probably get pretty big. Without strolling through the so-called "compound" myself, though, I'd be unwilling to accept the notion that the whole compound counts as one household. Further, some of the reports make it clear that there's multiple houses on the ranch property.

How would you feel if your child were taken away because your cousin, or your friend, or your neighbor, were abusing their kids? How close does the connection have to be in order for the government to have reasonable suspicion and thus justification to break up your family?

If the first response had been an arrest (or several) and removing 10-50 children from the compound, I'd have been able to accept that. When the story first broke, and I assumed that's what had happened, and so I took no issue with it. But displacing nearly 600 people as the first step of an investigation seems Constitutionally shaky. No one's even been charged. The man accused of abusing the girl turned himself in to his parole officer in Arizona, claiming to have not been in Texas in the past 30 years. That doesn't mean he's not lying, or that there couldn't be a case of mistaken identities, but it sure casts a bad light on the whole "investigation".

Worst of all, I wouldn't be surprised if, like the Short Creek raid of '53 (or the Waco raid of '93) this miscarriage of justice leads to militia groups and insular minority religions just hating and fearing the government that much more.

Shelter is a synonym for compound, I suppose.

via yahoo
Polygamist sect kids move to new shelter

By JENNIFER DOBNER, Associated Press Writer 49 minutes ago

SAN ANGELO, Texas - Child welfare officials are moving the 416 children seized in a raid on a West Texas polygamist compound to a new shelter.

Mothers of some of the children wrote to Gov. Rick Perry over the weekend. They say the children were getting sick in the crowded conditions.

The children were taken from the shelter earlier this month on suspicion that they were being physically and sexually abused by older members of the group. They were being transferred to the new shelter Monday.
Emphasis mine. It's probably a typo/substitution, or it could be a case of very poor synonym choice. For those still scratching their heads, all that use of shelter makes it sound like the kids were being abused in the place the government had extracted them too.

Note also that the headline was "kids move to", not the more accurate "kids moved to". As if the children had a lot of choice in which shelter they would occupy.

Neither error reflects well on Ms Dobner or her editor, but I suppose that's the risk of breaking news.